Real vs. Nominal Interest Rates

What is the real interest rate? We are told it is the nominal interest rate minus the inflation rate. This is a problematic idea. Let’s drill deeper into what they mean by inflation.

Economists insist that you can average the prices of apples, oranges, oil, rent, and a ski trip to St. Moritz.

You can’t add apples and oranges, or so the old expression claims. However, economists insist that you can average the prices of apples, oranges, oil, rent, and a ski trip to St. Moritz. This is despite problems that prevent them from agreeing on what should be included.

One problem is that we no longer need buggy whips. If buggy whips had been in the Consumer Price Index (CPI) before the advent of the car, what do you do when it goes out of general use? Substitute buggy whips with driving gloves (which most people don’t use)?

Another problem is that cars are vastly superior today than they were 50 years ago. Having had a chance to drive a classic 1965 Mustang with drum brakes, I can tell you it was scary to drive it on the highway even at 55 mph. I didn’t dare drive it faster, as the stopping distance felt like it would probably be half a mile. But, of course, every car on the road was whizzing past me at +20mph. Cars today cost more in dollars. How much do we attribute to inflation, and how much to the fact that they are better and contain many more gadgets?

The process of determining which items to include in CPI is politicized.

Worse still, the process of determining which items to include in CPI is politicized. Pensioners and union workers want CPI to rise as much as possible, because their income is tied to it. Pension fund managers want CPI to rise as little as possible, because their obligations are tied to it. Government officials also want a low CPI, as high inflation may be viewed as a measure of their mismanagement of the economy, and they would pay more to their unionized workers, and on their CPI-indexed bonds.

Finally, the effort to calculate the cost of living assumes that we can agree on what living means. To some, it may mean a rural lifestyle, cooking simple meals in a paid-off trailer. To others it may mean a rented urban rent loft, eating at hip foodie restaurants every night. To a large group of baby boomers, it means owning a large house, driving a BMW, and sending the kids to private school.

The very idea of calculating the CPI to serve as an indicator of inflation is flawed. Unfortunately, that doesn’t stop the government from compiling a CPI, and gleefully providing it to the economics and finance professions.

One use they make of the CPI is to adjust the market interest rate. Let’s look at how this works.

There is an actual rate at which actual lenders actually lend and actual borrowers actually borrow. Most days, the government conducts billions of dollars of transactions at this rate. Private parties conduct billions more.

I often think that modern monetary economics has no redeeming virtue. However, whenever I think that’s too harsh, I come across a notion like real vs. nominal rates.

So in keeping with the Orwellian character of our era, we’ll call this price observed in the market, the nominal rate.

Economists adjust this nominal rate. Guess what you get, if you subtract the CPI from the nominal rate of interest.

The real interest rate.

Got that? The nominal rate is the real, observed market price (itself manipulated by the Fed) and the real rate is when you subtract a controversial construct from it.

I often think that modern monetary economics has no redeeming virtue. However, whenever I think that’s too harsh, I come across a notion like real vs. nominal rates.

Related Posts:

1. What Did Capitalism Require to Emerge?
2. Rand v Hayek: Who Gets It Right?
3. The Moral Case against Vaccine Passports

   

About the Author: Keith Weiner

Keith Weiner is president of the Gold Standard Institute USA in Phoenix, AZ, and CEO of precious metals fund manager Monetary Metals. He created DiamondWare, a technology company that he sold to Nortel Networks in 2008. He speaks and writes about free markets, money, credit, and gold.